It appears the long fight is over. The Vallejo city council voted unanimously last night to file Chapter 9 bankruptcy for the city. Vallejo would become the largest city to ever declare bankruptcy in the state, and second only to Orange County for the largest public agency to do so.
"It's time to do something different. I don't like it. I don't want it," said Mayor Osby Davis, who then voted in favor of the bankruptcy.
CCN has been following this story for months, and our heart goes out to the city, its residents and its employees. What is most disconcerting is that this case may be a harbinger for localities across the state.
The city is facing a shortfall of over $15 million, with no reserves. Many cities do have the luxury of a cash reserve, but virtually every city is facing down the same issue that sank Vallejo: public safety pensions. In the LA Times rundown of last night's bankruptcy vote, the issue was framed like this:
"Many officials and residents attribute Vallejo's fiscal troubles to overly generous pay and benefits to the city's police and firefighters. The salaries for police and firefighters currently take up 75 to 80 percent of the city's general fund."
"Representatives from police, fire and electrical workers unions all argued against the Chapter 9 bankruptcy protection, saying that doing so would only make hiring already short-staffed public safety agencies even harder."
This is not an uncharacteristic summary of friction felt in city halls throughout the state, and puts both sides in an awkward position. Public Safety workers have negotiated their contracts in good faith, while on the other hand city officials have the unenviable task of laying blame for the city's financial challenges at the door of the community's most trusted leaders -- their police and fire workers.
With GASBY 21 and other pension issues coming to a boil, how are cities going to move forward and avoid Vallejo's fate? Might be a good time to revisit a guest editorial CCN ran last week -- Are Public Employees Retirement Benefits In Crisis?
You can also read all of CCN's stories on the pension reform issue on our Pension Reform category page.